Automatically translated version. May contain inaccuracies compared to the original.
After “Carthage,” the prosecution needs cleansing: why draft law No.16144 won’t help
Already today, 10 November, members of parliament plan to vote for a “renewal” of the prosecution carried out by the prosecutors themselves.
Instead of passing a bill for an open competition for the prosecutor general’s post, which the EU demands of Ukraine, parliamentarians want to vote for a pseudo-reform in draft law No.16144.
One of the main problems of the bill is precisely the lack of a competition for the prosecutor general’s position.
That means the key person in the system will remain a political appointee, fully dependent on the authorities.
Thus, the person who should independently investigate high-ranking officials becomes completely dependent on them.
⚠️ The model proposed by the Zelensky government in draft law No.16144 for all other prosecutors does not withstand any criticism.
All influence remains with people from within the system, who still depend on a politically appointed leader.
In addition to the prosecutor general remaining fully dependent on the authorities, we draw attention to the following provisions that do not withstand criticism:
▪️ Department heads in the Office of the Prosecutor General will be selected by commissions created by the Prosecutor General from among the OPG leadership and one representative of the Council of Prosecutors;
▪️ Heads of regional and district prosecutor’s offices, as well as their deputies, are to be selected by the Council of Prosecutors, that is, 15 prosecutors of various levels;
▪️ Heads of units of regional prosecutor’s offices, deputies of district prosecutor’s offices and heads of units of district prosecutor’s offices will be selected by commissions created by regional prosecutors, from among 6 leaders of the respective prosecutor’s offices and 1 a representative of the Council of Prosecutors.
So it’s not even that the majority would be prosecutors; in this model there is not even room for anyone outside the system.
The independence of the Council of Prosecutors is supposedly to be ensured by a vetting of candidates’ integrity and professional competence, which will be carried out by the newly created Council of Ethical Standards.
However, the composition of the Council of Ethical Standards is hard to call independent; rather the opposite.
❗️This is not a reform of the prosecution, but an attempt to freeze the current system under the guise of its renewal. Those who control the prosecution today will retain influence over appointments, vetting, and personnel decisions.
👉 Therefore, the Anti-Corruption Center (CPC) urges deputies not to vote for the pseudo-reform No.16144.
Olena Shcherban’s column on the imitation of reform: https://www.pravda.com.ua/columns/2026/11/10/8062014/