Automatically translated version. May contain inaccuracies compared to the original.
A true detective story is unfolding around the Stynavskoe oil and gas field in the Lviv region. It began long ago, back under Yanukovych, when a company connected to then-Environment Minister Mykola Zlochevskyi received a license to develop it. The license was later revoked and, logically, the extraction rights should have been put up for auction.
That’s what it seemed headed toward, but after the state company Ukrnafta tried to do that, it suddenly emerged that the Stynavskoe field’s boundaries overlap with the Semyhynivske field, a special permit for which belongs to Pari Naftogaz LLC, owned by Mykola Zlochevskyi’s daughters Anna and Karina.
The fields don’t just overlap at the surface. The key problem is that the permit issued to Pari Naftogaz lacks a depth restriction, even though the productive horizons of the two fields differ by only five meters: 2800–3600 meters for Stynavskoe and 3605–4540 meters for Semyhynivske. In the current version of Pari Naftogaz’s license, issued in July 2022, the depth limits are not specified.
In other words, the two fields are located one above the other. The crux of the discrepancy in the licenses is that, on the surface, the two fields partially overlap, but their known deposits lie at different depths. Yet Pari Naftogaz’s license does not indicate an upper or lower depth for the area.
The scandal arises for obvious reasons: if the absence of depth limits allows the Pari Naftogaz permit to be interpreted as covering the entire vertical volume of the subsurface under the adjacent territory, it can also be interpreted as the right to extract minerals to the full depth.
And the key question is equally obvious: why didn’t the permit state the depth, if the protocol of the State Commission on Mineral Reserves defines the interval of Semyhynivske field deposits as 3 605–4 540 meters? The answer suggests itself, but if you dig deeper and carefully study not only journalistic publications but also documents, the picture becomes far more serious than it appears at first glance.
Geological information as a separate asset
The most interesting details are revealed in indirect documents that allow tracing the history of Pari Naftogaz, its geological assets, and financial relationships. One such document is a resolution of the Supreme Court dated 18 December 2025 in case No. 320/35831/24. Formally, it’s a financial dispute between Pari LLC and the tax authority. But its text describes corporate decisions, transfer of the special permit, purchase of seismic survey results, and relations with other extraction companies.
In the previous paragraph, one name immediately stands out — Pari LLC, which does not appear in the scandal over the auction that never took place. Yet Pari LLC is directly related to it. That becomes clear when studying the court dispute with the tax authority.
For it suddenly turns out that on 17 September 2021, a new company — Pari Naftogaz LLC — was spun off from Pari LLC. The special permit No. 5398 to use the subsurface of the Semyhynivske field, issued back on 25 October 2011, was transferred to the new legal entity.
Pari Naftogaz LLC was registered on 7 December 2021. The company’s public profile lists Andrii Pavliv as director, the Cypriot company Semigin Holdings Limited as founder, and Anna and Karina Zlochevskyi as ultimate beneficiaries.
Prior to that, on 30 March 2021, Pari LLC signed a contract with GeoUnit for seismic exploration work. These studies were meant to clarify the site’s geological structure, identify promising hydrocarbon traps, and prepare recommendations for deep drilling.
When the permit passed to the new company, the survey results still required separate formalization. The court document notes that on 9 January 2023, Pari LLC and Pari Naftogaz LLC concluded contract No. 15-K/P. Its subject was the documented results of seismic data interpretation and the construction of a structural model of the Semyhynivske field — a report on paper and in electronic form.
In other words, the special permit and the geological information became subjects of separate legal operations. This is an important circumstance for understanding how the asset of the company that obtained the field-use rights was formed.
And here two crucial questions arise: what exact geological data were transferred to Pari Naftogaz, and were they used when designing extraction on sections adjacent to the Stynavskoe field? And what documents confirm that the actual use of these data conforms to the boundaries and conditions of the special permit?
There are, of course, no answers to these questions in that court decision — it was a tax dispute, and the court had no interest in the license and its change of owner. But the devil is in the details: the course of this case shows that preparing the Semyhynivske site for development included not only obtaining the permit, but also expensive studies whose results could be managed by a separate company.
Pylypivske field and the prosecutor’s strange forgetfulness
The interesting details don’t end there. They are extremely important for understanding how Mykola Zlochevskyi conducted business. The same court document describes Pari LLC’s relations with Binergo related to development of the Pylypivske gas field.
The parties concluded a production cooperation agreement on 16 July 2018. It provided for joint activities in drilling, equipping, and operating wells. Initially, net profit from the sale of extracted hydrocarbons after taxes and mandatory payments was split equally between participants, but an additional agreement dated 2 August 2023 changed the profit split: for the period from 16 October 2023 to 15 October 2024 Pari’s share was 30% and Binergo’s was 70%. From 16 October 2024 the agreement provided for a return to the 50 proportion on 50.
But we are interested not in the money split but in the Pylypivske field itself. It turns out there are also many noteworthy twists in its fate. In 2011 Pari received special permit No. 5384 for gas extraction at that field. In 2016 the Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor’s Office tried in court to annul the license, claiming that procedural requirements were violated when it was issued, in particular approvals from the Ivano-Frankivsk Regional Council.
In June 2017 the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine dismissed the prosecutor’s suit as time-barred. The permit remained in force. Of course, nothing can be asserted definitively, but the prosecutor’s missed deadlines here look as discordant a detail as the strange forgetfulness about specifying the depth of horizons in the Semyhynivske field.
In this context it should be recalled that not long before, the prosecutor’s office lost an appeal seeking annulment of four more special permits issued to Pari and two other Zlochevskyi firms — Tekhnoresurs LLC and Nadragaz LLC. The reason was the same — the SAP missed filing deadlines.
Dispute over gas prices
The same tax case also includes a dispute over Pari LLC’s sale of natural gas in 2019–2023. The tax authority argued that the company sold gas at prices below usual market levels, which, according to its calculations, led to understatement of financial results by 465,18 million hryvnias.
The courts disagreed with the tax authority’s approach, and the Supreme Court upheld the conclusions of the lower courts.
This episode cannot be presented as proof of tax evasion: the court decision favored the company on the disputed issues. Nevertheless, it shows the scale of financial operations in the extraction business and the need to analyze not only licenses but sales contracts, counterparty structures, and cash flows.
A bit about the money
Pari Naftogaz’s financial statements show figures that warrant separate verification: in 2025 the company reported assets of 174,5 million hryvnias, liabilities of 217,9 million, and a net loss of 12,5 million. Meanwhile, in 2026 the quarterly figures changed significantly: assets — 417,8 million hryvnias, liabilities — 501,3 million, loss for the reporting period — 40 million hryvnias.
These numbers by themselves do not indicate violations, but they raise questions. With what funds were the geological exploration works financed? What loans, intra-group settlements, and obligations formed the balance sheet? How were rights to geological information and seismic survey results reflected? How did assets change after the special permit transfer and corporate changes?
It’s especially important to establish what lies behind the asset increase in 2026: new investments, revaluation, intra-group transfer of property, or another factor. But that requires financial statements and primary documents available only to state bodies.
The 2011 license year
Now let us return to the license that sparked the scandal. In the context of the foregoing, the theory of someone in the execution chain “forgetting” to specify the development horizon depth raises, to say the least, justified doubts.
If this were not Ukraine, the executor would long ago have cut a deal with investigators and revealed the necessary details — in particular, why, given different intervals of deposit occurrence, the dispute over the sections is considered mainly through the intersection of their surface boundaries.
At the same time, it should be understood that a five-meter depth difference between the specified intervals by itself does not prove the absence of any geological connections between the deposits and does not allow, without studying project documentation, the conclusion that one development cannot affect another.
If the documents do not define the lower boundary of the area, the question arises how the regulator interprets the boundaries of the granted right and what restrictions follow from the documents on the basis of which the permit was issued.
Here the most important contradiction of the whole story emerges. On the one hand, the geological reserves cited in the investigation materials have a concrete interval of occurrence. On the other, the wording of the current permit form contains no corresponding depth limitation.
If these facts are confirmed by the complete set of documents, the question arises whether the discrepancy between the geological justification and the text of the license creates an unjustifiably broad interpretation of the rights of a private subsurface user. Spoiler: it does. With all the consequences.
Document: PDF proof of the original version of the news item "Прогалини в ліцензіях і багатомільйонні оборудки: як компанії ексміністра-втікача Злочевського привласнюють нафтогазові родовища України". It records the publication content at the moment of the first scan, the preservation date and the source: Rozsliduvach.