Automatically translated version. May contain inaccuracies compared to the original.
Delivery of sand for Kyiv dikes could become a “gold mine”: tender prices marked up by 3–4 times
After the shelling of bridges in Kyiv, authorities for the first time since the war began have started to consider how to maintain connection between the left and right banks. According to Infrastructure Minister Mykola Kalashnyk, they are considering building earthen dikes with pontoon crossings.
A dike is a fairly simple structure made of stone and other bulk materials. The main cost is the building materials themselves and their delivery.
Imagine that the authorities find the will not to steal on building materials and not to buy them from anyone at any price. Instead, they take them from state quarries of Ukrzaliznytsia.
But there are really few options for organizing delivery around Kyiv by the state. Delivery of building materials is handled by construction and procurement firms. The whole question comes down to the price at which they are paid. That is, how much it will cost to transport 1 tons/cubic meter of sand or crushed stone for 1 kilometers.
There are many benchmarks. For example, Avtostrada is currently building a water main 40 kilometers from frontline Zaporizhzhia, where a lot of sand is needed. In that estimate the price for transport is 1 ton/kilometer equals 8,45 UAH (respectively 13,85 UAH per cubic meter/km; prices below include VAT).
The National Institute for Infrastructure Development provides data on the cost of transporting bulk materials by dump trucks in Kyiv region in August at 8,08 UAH per ton/kilometer (citing the Recovery Service in Kyiv region and the same Avtostrada; other firms for some reason did not report). With bulk density of sand 1,4 tons per cubic meter, that equals 11,30 UAH to transport one cubic meter of sand one kilometer.
So a normal transport price is at the level of 8–9 UAH per ton/kilometer (12–13 UAH per cubic meter of sand).
But Nashi Hroshi analyzed recent large construction tenders across Kyiv. It turned out there is a peculiar atmosphere here. One that easily pushes the price to… 20 UAH and even 37 UAH per cubic meter/km!
.fancybox-div {text-align: center; font-size: 12px; margin: 0 0 20px 0;}
Delivery of sand for Kyiv dikes could become a “gold mine”: tender prices marked up by 3–4 times
Delivery of sand for Kyiv dikes could become a “gold mine”: tender prices marked up by 3–4 times
Thus transport prices in capital tenders are 3–4 times higher than what we identified above as normal prices for delivery of building materials. Therefore it’s simply a gold mine. Here’s a simple calculation.
Take one cubic meter of sand and transport it across Kyiv to build a dike; suppose it’s 15 kilometers from any outskirts of the city. A typical dump truck carries 10 cubic meters. At the normal price, the cost of delivery by truck is:
13 UAH per 1 cubic/ km × 15 km × 10 cubic meters in the truck = 1950 UAH.
If you take the twice-as-high price from the estimate for reconstruction of the Peremohy/Hetmana interchange, then one truck would already cost 3 900 UAH.
A very fat margin. And it will churn out money like a perpetual motion machine. After all, building dikes is just filling the river with various loose building materials. Which simply need to be delivered there. And even if Ukraine’s international donors stand with a counter and count how many cubic meters were actually delivered, the inflated price will still enrich the beneficiaries.
Minister of Infrastructure Kalashnyk slipped that the cost of this construction could amount to tens of billions of hryvnias. Very roughly one can say that the cost of delivering building materials, if massively inflated, could reach half of the entire estimate.
Authors: Yurii Nikolov, Hanna Kysliakova, Nashi Hroshi
Document: PDF proof of the original version of the news item "Доставка піску для дамб у Києві може стати «золотою жилою»: ціни в тендерах завищені у 3–4 рази". It records the publication content at the moment of the first scan, the preservation date and the source: ANTIKOR.