Back
Original version

⚔️ Institutional makhnovshchyna: why the law-enforcers’ war is a copy of 1918 year Carthage versus Janus. Serving noti...

Automatically translated version. May contain inaccuracies compared to the original.

⚔️ Institutional makhnovshchyna: why the law-enforcers’ war is a copy of 1918 year

Carthage versus Janus.

Serving notices of suspicion to top officials in the anti-corruption bloc and internal agency wars — this is a return to the classic Ukrainian “otamanshchyna.” History has reached again for its old template.

Signs of legal makhnovshchyna today:

📌Autonomous “detachments.” Law enforcement uses the Criminal Procedure Code not to protect the state, but to mutually destroy one another. Institutions turn into rival rebel camps.

📌Temporary alliances. As in Nestor Makhno’s time, the rules change weekly. The authors of suspicions and the subjects of cases swap places with kaleidoscopic speed.

📌Dirty-tricks war. Public “leaks” and mutual searches replace systemic justice.

The main lesson of history

Hegel wrote: events repeat themselves twice — as tragedy and as farce. In the 1918–1920 years, the otamans’ internecine conflicts led to the loss of independence (tragedy). Today, during a major war, the bickering between agencies looks like a farce that destroys society’s and Western allies’ trust.

History teaches: an internal war of “otamans” during an external invasion always opens the gates to a third player. And that player ultimately destroys both sides.

❗️OFFICE OF PURIFICATION ⚖️ SEND NEWS

🚀 Read more on our FaceBook…

Screenshot of a Telegram post: ⚔️ Institutional makhnovshchyna: why the law-enforcers’ war is a copy of 1918 y…

⚔️ Інституційна махновщина: чому війна силовиків — це копія 1918 року

Карфаген проти Януса.

Вручення підозр топпосадовцям антикорупційного блоку та внутрішні війни відомств — це повернення класичної української «отаманщини». Історія знову дістала свій старий шаблон.

Ознаки правової махновщини сьогодні:

📌Автономні «загони». Силовики використовують КПК не для захисту держави, а для взаємного знищення. Інститути перетворюються на ворогуючі повстанські табори.

📌Тимчасові союзи. Як і за часів Нестора Махна, правила змінюються щотижня. Автори підозр і фігуранти справ міняються місцями з калейдоскопічною швидкістю.

📌Війна компроматів. Публічні «зливи» та взаємні обшуки підміняють собою системне правосуддя.

Головний урок історії

Гегель писав: події повторюються двічі — як трагедія і як фарс. У 1918–1920 роках міжусобиці отаманів призвели до втрати незалежності (трагедія). Сьогодні, під час великої війни, гризня відомств виглядає як фарс, що руйнує довіру суспільства та західних союзників.

Історія вчить: внутрішня війна «отаманів» під час зовнішньої навали завжди відкриває ворота третьому гравцю. І він у підсумку знищує обидві сторони.

❗️ОФІС ОЧИЩЕННЯ ⚖️ НАДІСЛАТИ НОВИНУ

🚀 Читай більше на нашому FaceBook…

Screenshot of a Telegram post: ⚔️ Інституційна махновщина: чому війна силовиків — це копія 1918 року Карфаген…
Download Download proof

Other channel publications

Scanned Telegram publication

We continue the story of the Crimean “turncoats” in robes who somehow evade real punishment. Earlier we wrote about granting powers in the High Council of Justice to Judge Andriy Maznytsia — the former deputy head of the Appellate Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea. In 2014 he, together with then-court chairman Valeriy Chornobuk, took an active part in changing the flags on the courthouse building and personally taught Ukrainian judges Russian laws on camera for the occupiers. https://t....

Scanned Telegram publication

A party trick from a piece of paper: how Hryhoriy Usyk, head of the High Council of Justice, “lit up” at the anniversary of the HACC 🥱 Recently, at the anniversary of the creation of the High Anti-Corruption Court, the controversial Head of the High Council of Justice, Hryhoriy Usyk, “lit up.” HACC judges who attended the court’s anniversary celebration share behind-the-scenes impressions: the main “highlight” of the festivities was the speech by the controversial head of the High Council of Ju...

Scanned Telegram publication

🍎 HOW MUCH DOES FREEDOM COST IN UKRAINE? Why does Ukrainian justice protect the “elite”? ⚖️ The High Anti‑Corruption Court, for receiving a bribe of 2 000 US dollars, sentenced the judge of the Pavlohrad City and District Court of Dnipropetrovsk region, Oleksandr Shcherbyna, to 5 years of imprisonment with confiscation of property. https://t.me/hcacofficial/7036 📸 Footage of the judge’s arrest with 1 000 USD in a bag among apples circulated online last year. We are also publishing it, alongsid...

Scanned Telegram publication

“Strike” panel of the North Economic Court of Appeal: how long before the former HCC member gets caught? ⏳⚖️ Former members of the High Council of Justice and their relatives have been officially added to the staff of the Northern Economic Court of Appeal. Among the newly minted judges are Mykola Moroz, Yuliia Bokova, and Hanna Ponomariova. While Moroz and Ponomariova are taking an accelerated course on “how to be a judge” at the National School of Judges and preparing to take the oath, whisper...

Deleted Telegram publication

New competition for the Supreme Court: when impunity breeds permissiveness or the storming of the Supreme Court ⚠️ Do you remember the loud scandal of “raimovshchyna,” when certain members of the High Qualification Commission of Judges and the High Council of Justice successfully pushed themselves, their relatives, and close associates into the appellate courts? Back then the system swallowed it, and the organizers got away with everything. But the laws of corrupt psychology are relentless: if t...

Scanned Telegram publication

New Supreme Court contest: when impunity breeds permissiveness or an assault on the Supreme Court ⚠️ Do you remember the high‑profile scandal of “raimovshchyna,” when certain members of the High Qualifications Commission of Judges and the High Council of Justice successfully pushed themselves, their relatives, and close associates into the appellate courts? Back then the system swallowed it, and the organizers got away with it. But the laws of corrupt psychology are relentless: if the first braz...