Automatically translated version. May contain inaccuracies compared to the original.
‼️Fine of 170 thousand hryvnias for military registration: how does the new law threaten Ukrainian business?
🙋🏻♂️ The Verkhovna Rada made amendments to the law that have raised serious questions about the liability of company executives for violations of military registration rules.
Fine — 170 000 hryvnias! And most interestingly, the relevant provision was added to a law concerning bank accounts and combating fraud.
Who can be fined, who will make the decisions, and how can businesses protect their rights?
❓ What did the Verkhovna Rada adopt?
📃 In the second reading of draft law No. 16013 on combating “drop-schemes,” parliament supported amendment No. 11 by Dmytro Razumkov.
It provides changes to Article 210-1 of the Code of Administrative Offenses.
❗ For the corresponding violation of military registration rules a fixed fine of 170 000 hryvnias is established.
This is administrative, not criminal, liability.
❓ Who can be fined?
⚖️ The provision envisages liability for an official whose breach led to a person being placed on the military register who was not subject to such registration.
But the legislator did not explicitly clarify which specific official is meant!
This creates a risk of ambiguous application of the provision regarding:
▪️ officials of the Territorial Recruitment Centers and Conscription Offices;
▪️ company executives;
▪️ personnel department employees;
▪️ those responsible for personal military records.
‼️ Such indeterminacy can become a problem for business.
❓ Can an employer register a person with the Territorial Recruitment Center?
NO ❌
☝🏻 It is necessary to distinguish powers:
▪️ The Territorial Recruitment Centers and Conscription Offices carry out military registration of citizens within their powers.
▪️ The company maintains personal military records of employees, compiles lists, and transmits the necessary information.
The employer does not have the authority to independently make a decision to place a citizen on the military register at the Territorial Recruitment Center.
❓ What is the main legal danger?
⚖️ To hold someone liable it is necessary to prove:
▪️ the specific official duty of the person;
▪️ the fact of its breach;
▪️ the person’s guilt;
▪️ the causal link between the breach and the illegal registration.
❗ The mere fact of employment at the company or that the HR officer maintained military records is not enough for a lawful imposition of the fine!
❓ Who will impose the fines?
📃 According to Article 235 of the Code of Administrative Offenses, cases under Article 210-1 are considered by authorized officials of the Territorial Recruitment Centers and Conscription Offices.
Thus a fine can be imposed without a prior court decision.
⚠️ This raises questions of objectivity, especially when the violation is related to actions of officials of the very Territorial Recruitment Center.
❓ Why are there questions about the legislative procedure?
📃 The amendment regarding military registration was included in draft law No. 16013, dedicated to banking fraud.
At the same time, a separate draft law No. 15115 on liability for violations of military registration was under consideration in the specialized committee.
❗ A question arises about compliance with Article 116 of the Verkhovna Rada Rules and the principle of legal certainty enshrined in Article 8 of the Constitution of Ukraine.
❓ How can business protect itself from the fine of 170 thousand hryvnias?
👨🏻⚖️ Company executives need to:
▪️ verify orders appointing those responsible for military registration;
▪️ ensure proper maintenance of personal records;
▪️ document the transfer of information to the Territorial Recruitment Center;
▪️ keep confirmations of the fulfillment of their duties;
▪️ demand evidence of a specific violation and guilt;
▪️ if there are grounds, challenge unlawful fines.
❗ A fine cannot be based on assumptions or solely on the fact of another person’s illegal registration.
❓ And who will be responsible for unlawful decisions of state officials?
⚖️ Article 56 of the Constitution of Ukraine guarantees the right to compensation for damage caused by unlawful decisions and actions of state bodies.
However, entrepreneurs often have to spend significant money and time on court disputes to protect their rights.
Ukrainian businesses operate under conditions of war, shelling, staff shortages, and energy constraints. And now they face an additional risk of a fine of 170 thousand hryvnias for an ambiguously worded violation.
❗ The state should clearly delineate the powers of the Territorial Recruitment Centers and employers, not create new tools of potential pressure on business.