Back
Original version

This week the High Council of Justice dismissed five judges: - Two — retired; - Two — resigned at their own request;...

Automatically translated version. May contain inaccuracies compared to the original.

This week the High Council of Justice dismissed five judges:

- Two — retired;

- Two — resigned at their own request;

- One — in connection with being subject to disciplinary liability.

At that, one of the judges who resigned at her own request had served in the position for less than two years. The other — only six.

The judge dismissed for drinking on the job, Oksana Zvyagina, worked for a little more than 2 years. At the same time, since February 2026 she had been suspended from administering justice by the decision of the Disciplinary Chamber.

So in just one week the judicial system lost three judges who should have continued to serve for another 15–20 years.

The Zvyagina case shows overall that neither competitions nor integrity interviews are a guarantee of selecting an adequate judge.

Screenshot of a Telegram post: This week the High Council of Justice dismissed five judges: - Two — retired; -…

Цього тижня ВРП звільнила пʼять суддів:

- Двох - у відставку;

- Двох - за власним бажанням;

- Одну - у звʼязку з притягненням до дисциплінарної відповідальності.

При цьому одна з суддів, які звільнилися за власним бажанням, пропрацювала на посаді менше двох років. А інша - лише шість.

Звільнена через пияцтво на робочому місці суддя Оксана Звягіна пропрацювала трохи більше 2 років. При цьому з лютого 2026 року вона була відсторонена від здійснення правосуддя за рішенням Дисциплінарної палати.

Тобто лише за тиждень судова система втратила трьох суддів, які мали би працювати ще по 15-20 років.

Історія зі Звягіною взагалі показує, що ні конкурси, ні співбесіди на доброчесність - не є гарантією добору адекватного судді.

Screenshot of a Telegram post: Цього тижня ВРП звільнила пʼять суддів: - Двох - у відставку; - Двох - за власн…
Download Download proof

Other channel publications

Scanned Telegram publication

Today the High Qualifications Commission of Judges (HQCJ) and the Expert Council were deciding on candidates for the Specialized Administrative Court of Appeal. Reminder: 10 judicial vacancies have been identified in this court. To begin work, at least half need to be appointed. 23 candidates reached the stage of joint interviews. 21 candidates appeared for the interview itself. Before that, the Expert Council determined that 19 out of 23 were not of integrity. For the rest, the votes of the Exp...

Scanned Telegram publication

Legalization of property worth 26 million UAH: former head of the Commercial Cassation Court Bohdan Lviv has been notified of suspicion. The NABU and SAP have notified former head of the CC of the Supreme Court Bohdan Lviv of suspicion in legalizing (laundering) property obtained by criminal means, in an especially large amount. In addition, two other persons have been notified of suspicion in committing the crime — the judge’s former subordinate and her mother. During the period 2021–2022 years...

Scanned Telegram publication

Last week, candidates for the district administrative courts and judges who expressed a desire to be transferred through the competition chose their future courts. Let's recall the numbers. The vacant positions in first-instance administrative courts for which the High Council of Justice conducted this competition were 272. 268 people applied to the High Council of Justice to participate in this competition. 263 people passed the admission stage. 242 people chose positions in the courts, 15 of w...

Scanned Telegram publication

The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court issued an important decision regarding the qualification assessment of judges for fitness to hold their position. By this decision, the GC SC determined at which stage a judge may challenge the High Qualification Commission of Judges’ decision finding them unfit for their position. When the HQCJ adopts a negative decision based on a judge’s assessment as to fitness for their position, it submits a proposal to the High Council of Justice for the judge’s dism...

Scanned Telegram publication

The Office of the President published two decrees appointing judges. Earlier last week four more were published. It appears that judges are being appointed according to two criteria: 1. “Lost” decrees from 1-7 years are located, signed, and published. 2. New submissions from the HCJ are processed as quickly as possible, decrees are signed, and also published. This indicates a change in the Office of the President’s policy on judicial appointments after the Mudra-Mykitas recordings exposed storie...

Scanned Telegram publication

The Plenum of the Supreme Court, which last Friday attempted to decide on the necessity of holding a new competition for the SC, failed to reach a decisive vote on that issue. The votes of the Supreme Court judges split almost in half. Later it turned out that the counting commission also does not know how to add up in a column. Therefore the voting results were annulled, and the issue of announcing the competition will be considered at the next plenum. Recall that the SC already has more than 5...