Automatically translated version. May contain inaccuracies compared to the original.
On the one hand, he is one of Ukraine’s most sought-after lawyers in top corruption cases. At different times, his law firm has represented clients such as former MP Maxim Mikitas, Lviv mayor Andriy Sadovyi, and former parliamentarian Serhiy Pashynsky. At the same time, Yevhen Hrushovets and his colleagues defend NABU detective Ruslan Magamedsarullov in a case being investigated by the SBU.
On the other hand, at the start of the full-scale invasion, the lawyer went to defend Ukraine as a volunteer, participated in the operation to liberate Snake Island, adjusting fire on Russian positions. After returning to his legal practice, he became the first head of the Public Anti-Corruption Council under the Ministry of Defense, created after the egg procurement scandal involving 17 hryvnias, which ZN.UA exposed.
Now Hrushovets is a member of the competition commission for selecting candidates for vacant administrative positions in the Specialized Anti-C corruption Prosecutor’s Office (SAPO). He admits that it is extremely difficult to negotiate with SAP prosecutors for deals for his clients.
Where is the line between the right to defense and abusing procedural rights? Why do top corruption cases take years to reach verdicts? And what responsibility do not only the investigation and the prosecutor’s office bear for the state of justice, but also the defense community itself? ZN.UA spoke with Yevhen Hrushovets about this.
About NABU and defending suspects in corruption cases
— Mr. Hrushovets, sources explain that about the search of NABU detective Ruslan Magamedrasulov, which the SBU conducted in July 2025 year, you were informed by a person not from the Bureau but familiar with mass searches of detectives. Tell us how everything happened and why you decided to take on Magamedrasulov’s defense? After all, your firm represents in court those whom NABU suspects of corruption.
— A person who knew the situation with law enforcement and NABU called me and asked me to come to Magamedrasulov for the search, noting that there were rather strange movements. This phone call happened at noon, when the search was almost over. That’s how I became acquainted with this case, because I didn’t know Ruslan before.
We, colleagues, do not provide defense services to everyone who comes to us. We have a set of criteria by which we decide whether to take a client or not. I cannot say that we really wanted to defend Magamedrasulov. Among the reasons that dictated this decision was the fact that there were few lawyers defending detectives in the self-government community. Lawyers begin talking among themselves and then telling their clients that if someone defends a detective, it means he cooperates with him.
However, there is not only condemnation from lawyers. There have been cases when, for example, a lawyer could be mobilized because of a certain case. There were instances when people from the TTC and the mobilization teams arrived and took the lawyer right during investigative actions. And then they threatened: if he continues to participate in any case concerning this suspect, he will be sent to “zero.” That is, the person was mobilized specifically because of a certain case. It turns out that defending the Fatherland is used as a punishment.
Of course, I support mobilization. Ukraine must be defended. I myself joined as a volunteer at the beginning of the full-scale invasion. And now someone says to the lawyer: “You will defend further, you’ll go to zero.” What are you threatening with? Defending our country?
— Society often perceives defending suspects in corruption as a personal value choice of the lawyer, not as professional work that includes defending those we do not like. At the same time, lawyers are criticized for defending NABU detectives. So you get hit from both sides?
— Lawyers are also a cross-section of society. You cannot separate a lawyer from the environment in which he lives.
And regarding Magamedrasulov, we decided to officially enter his defense when we saw that there was complete injustice in this case. I have an immediate reaction that on the position of a NABU detective, there could be my close relative or friend. And if it happens once, it will happen again. For this I am ready to take risks.
A lawyer can be removed from a case in various ways. In one proceeding, where opponents did not want me to represent victims, criminal cases were opened against me. Then the investigator called and said, “We want to question you, because you owe someone money, you didn’t pay it, and that is fraud.” Then a whole media campaign was launched against me. So there is little pleasant here. The more complex the case, the more workload and risks.
— How do you view the reform of the legal profession envisaged by EU integration obligations of Ukraine, which the parliament and the National Association of Advocates of Ukraine block? It seems the advocacy community is ossified and does not work on the reputation of the profession, which you are talking about. What, in your view, should the advocacy community itself do to strengthen trust in the profession?
— In our country, probably there are few so “monolithic” spheres as the bar. And that is not a compliment. Reform is certainly needed. The bar self-government must hear criticism and answer questions from its own colleagues. Still, changes start with oneself. Among the lawyers I work with and closely communicate with, I cannot name anyone I would consider dishonest. Perhaps this sounds somewhat pompous, but I’ll say it as I truly believe: we are united by certain moral principles, an understanding of what is permissible in the profession. That said, my circle is not the entire bar.
Rules must work for everyone, and decisions of self-government bodies must be clear and reasoned. In particular, regarding complaints against lawyers. I myself, in one proceeding, received a complaint from a law enforcement body, which I interpret as pressure on defense. So we must examine: did the lawyer truly violate professional duties or did he simply become inconvenient for the investigation? Punishing for a violation and punishing for active defense of a client are different things. Here too, balance is needed. And the community itself must respond to unscrupulous acts. It is unacceptable to demand accountability from an investigator, a prosecutor, or a judge, and to tell a colleague, “Well, that’s our guy, let’s keep silent.” Defending the independence of the lawyer should be protected, but covering up his violations — definitely not.
— Has the war changed your attitude toward detectives and prosecutors you find on opposite sides in court?
— I think the war has intensified all this. And the feeling of “ally” and “opponent” is actually absolutely normal. In court you have one attitude toward the prosecutor. However, when the prosecutor defends the state with a weapon in hand, in this context he is a friend to me. And I’ll support him.
Let me tell you an story. At the very beginning of the full-scale Russian invasion I met in central Kyiv some NABU staff. I asked: guys, is there a task you can help with? Then, together with colleagues and clients, I was engaged in aerial reconnaissance. NABU representatives agreed. And a few days after completing all documents, in the Brovary district I worked with a drone, and they were a cover crew. And we rode into mortar fire together. We drove together, hid from shells together. And in such a situation you really understand the value of people who are near. I simply offered, they took it and drove. I remembered this act for life. But if tomorrow in a proceeding they violate my client’s rights, I will challenge their actions just as well.
About the SAP competition and working institutions
— In October of this year you were elected to the competition commission for selecting candidates for vacant administrative positions in SAP, instead of lawyer Oleksiy Shevchuk. His term was appointed by the Attorney General Ruslan Kravchenko, despite the appeal of 60 public organizations that opposed this appointment. Later Kravchenko terminated Shevchuk’s powers. Your appointment coincided with your client Serhiy Pashynsky’s agreement with the investigation in the NABU case. Why did you decide to join this commission?
— As far as I understand, my predecessor still has plans for this place. At least he challenges the termination of his powers, so the Office of the Attorney General (OAG) will still receive lawsuits.
Regarding my decision to run for the commission. I was in the second and third convocations of the NABU Public Control Council. This is the commission that selected the first batches of detectives. Then and now I wanted NABU to come out as a truly effective institution, not another body created at the request of Western partners for a checkbox.
In the case of SAP — the motivation is similar.
Undoubtedly, there are questions about the work of NABU detectives as well, and some today sound very sharp, but I still consider NABU one of the most effective law enforcement agencies. They are not afraid to bring suspicion against even the president’s office head, although, I think, it is morally difficult for them too. And when we see certain actions by, for example, the SBU or the State Bureau of Investigation (DBR), that, of course, raises questions.
When a prosecutor passes an objective competition, he forms independence for himself. And this prosecutor will be chosen not by Yevhen Hrushovets, but by a commission consisting of six members, some of whom are international experts.
But I know SAP prosecutors from the other side as well. In all my professional experience — I have been working as a lawyer for 15 years — the most difficult thing is to make deals with SAP. It’s “torture.” I sometimes call them “astronauts” in a good sense, or say that they live in some “own world.” You have to have several meetings, find convincing arguments to win the best conditions for the client. They simply don’t concede easily. And that’s good, because these people have a core.
However, being inflexible by itself does not mean you work well. If the defense brings arguments, you check them, explain why you disagree. And if you are wrong, have the character to admit and correct it. Standing firm just to stand firm is hardly principled.
Therefore, I would not want SAP to begin a revolution of “built processes,” and I truly wish that this institution works even better independently of who leads it.
— And if during the competition a real or potential conflict of interest arises?
— If such circumstances arise, I will inform the commission, explain what they are, and declare self-recusal regarding the particular candidate. This is expressly provided by law. I will not participate in collecting information about this person, nor in evaluating them, nor in voting for them. Then the commission will act according to the regulations.
And here you must understand: Hrushovets’s vote is, conditionally, only 16% of the decision; I am not the sole arbiter in selecting a person. And it is important to me that the commission makes consolidated decisions. So if three say “this is the best candidate,” and three say “absolutely not,” we need to analyze why we see him so differently. I want that after the competition we can confidently say: this is the person, this is why we chose her. And explain it so that society also understands our choice.
— And you defend the detective and you also choose prosecutors for the anti-corruption prosecutor’s office. You’re burying yourself in it.
— I want institutions to work, and I don’t want SAP to choose a person who has obligations to someone. Because look at the OAG. We have one attorney general, then another, and meanwhile society perceives ordinary prosecutors as “accomplices” of the AG. Although that is not necessarily so. Take, for example, the story with former Attorney General Kravchenko and the NABU investigation “Carthage.” This story again makes us think about how our system works. People come to high positions, gain huge powers, but do not always think about the responsibility they take. It is possible to go down in history as the attorney general who managed to organize normal work of the system, to build the prosecutor’s authority. But it seems to some that their own ambitions and financial success are more important than the result.
— How do you assess institutionally and legislatively the Lozoov’s amendments in top corruption cases? Do they drag out the process? Because public organizations monitoring such cases, as well as some leadership of law enforcement agencies, advocate for their abolition.
— I’ll say an unpopular thing. The very principle of restricting terms and court supervision I assess positively. But here you must distinguish different provisions that are called Lozoov’s amendments. The investigation term until the notification of suspicion was canceled back in 2024 year. And I believe that in that mechanism there was a benefit: it forced the investigator to explain what is happening with the proceeding.
How did it work? In a proceeding concerning a grave or especially grave crime, the investigation had 18 months. You don’t make it — and you go to the investigative judge and explain: here is what I did, here is what I haven’t done yet, here is why additional time is needed. And the court decides whether there are grounds to grant this time. What is wrong with that?
Should a person live for years with the prospect of someday getting a suspicion? Or should the victim wait ten years for the investigator to finally take up their case? During this time some evidence may disappear, and witnesses may simply forget what happened.
People tell me: the investigator is running late, he has a huge workload. I know that exists. However, in this case one must deal with workload, the number of investigators, and organization of work. The staffing crisis in law enforcement should not mean that everyone must wait for years.
Have there been problems with applying these norms? I will not deny there were. But together with the name “Lozoov’s amendments” many different things were assembled, and now the requirement for the investigation to work within reasonable timeframes is also presented as an obstacle.
I categorically disagree with this. The term can be extended if there are justified grounds. For example, a highly complex international case or other objective circumstances. But this must be explained to the court. Simply saying “we have top corruption” is not enough.
I believe that within a year and a half to three years the investigation should be able to show a concrete result and explain where the case is heading. If not, I have questions about the organization of the investigation. And cancellation of the terms will not answer that.
— But there is another side of the problem. Because of the expiry of pre-trial investigation terms, many resonant proceedings in top corruption cases have already been closed — often due to formal procedural nuances during the extension of these terms. Do you not think that in such cases procedural norms of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine (CPC) turn into a mechanism to avoid responsibility when society still does not get a substantive answer: is the official guilty or not?
— I would not say that procedural terms are some general loophole for avoiding responsibility. Certainly, someone tries to use them that way, but to conclude that the rules themselves hinder investigating cases would be wrong. The CPC provides tools for this. Look at what happened in a particular case. The case began in 2016 year, and it is being investigated in 2022-th or 2023-th year. What did they do all this time? Then they notified of suspicion. How much time passed before transferring the case to court? And then look at how it was heard. Because when proceedings are closed due to terms, everyone discusses the last decision. I want to understand what the previous years were spent on.
Of course, there are cases with thousands of volumes. They need to be read, analyzed, that takes time. But if as a result society did not get an answer, whether the official is guilty or not, we must understand why that happened. Simply saying “the terms hindered us” seems to me a evasive answer.
— But even when the investigation is within terms, top corruption cases may be litigated for years. Trials are prolonged due to changing defense attorneys, absences, sick leaves, or mobilization — and meanwhile, statute of limitations expires. Now there are proposals to suspend them during court proceedings or mobilization. How do you view this? Is it a way to avoid accountability or a risk of violating defendants’ rights?
— Look: for a grave crime the general statute of limitations is ten years, and for a particularly grave one — fifteen. In this regard the question arises: why can’t law enforcement and the judiciary figure out in this time whether the official is guilty? Ten to fifteen years for sick leaves or frequent non-appearance of defense attorneys at hearings? Initiatives that effectively allow continuing prosecution indefinitely I do not support.
And you should not record every sick leave, non-appearance of an attorney, or mobilization as abuse. Again, you must look at what is happening in a particular case. In cases where we work, there are accused who have been mobilized and are represented by several lawyers. They participate in hearings: someone via videoconference, someone comes in person when service conditions allow. So one must determine whether a person truly cannot participate in the proceedings.
The same with lawyers. If a person has several defense attorneys, the absence of one does not always prevent a hearing. This is clearly visible from the practices of the High Anti-Corruption Court (HACC).
Even before a case reaches court, years can pass. You cannot keep all that time in abeyance, and then explain the expiry of the statute of limitations only by the defense’s conduct. I believe current procedural mechanisms allow moving cases forward. The question is how they are used and how work is organized at each stage.
— The EU demands depoliticization of the prosecutor’s office. One option is an open competition for the position of attorney general with the participation of Ukrainian and international experts. But there is also an argument that this could limit the president’s constitutional powers. You have experience serving on competition commissions. Do you think it is possible, under current circumstances in Ukraine, to depoliticize the prosecutor’s office without a competition for the position of attorney general?
— Take the Office of the Attorney General, where over the years the attorney generals changed every one and a half to two years. This is very bad for the institution, and for prosecutors in general. And although they are our opponents in court, I want prosecutors to be strong, to have legal responsibility for what they do. Because “a new broom sweeps clean in its own way.”
I am sure there are many adequate prosecutors working in the OAG; they simply need to be shown the principles of work. Unfortunately, some personnel decisions by the authorities have eroded trust in state institutions. And they harm the state in the long run.
I am for a competition for the position of attorney general. Interim people in this system make things worse. A competition will determine candidates, and the president will choose from among them to nominate to the Verkhovna Rada.
Document: PDF proof of the original version of the news item "Адвокат Євген Грушовець: «Я за конкурс на посаду генпрокурора»". It records the publication content at the moment of the first scan, the preservation date and the source: ZN.ua.